People who were excluded from the United States Constitution answers questions
Upgrade /Log in
Options /Log out
Early Europe
Central Asia
Islamic Empire
Native Americans
S./Central America
American History

Equal Rights for Some

Abigail Adams
Abigail Adams

During and after the American Revolution, when the rich white men were writing the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, many people who were not rich, or white, or men thought maybe this was their chance to get equal rights too. They wrote to the men who were writing the Constitution and asked them to give women, and black people, and poor people, Jews, and Native Americans equal rights with rich white men. These people did win some rights for themselves, but they couldn't get equal rights with rich white men.


In 1776, Abigail Adams wrote to her husband, John Adams, who was one of the men writing the Constitution, to ask him "in the new Code of Laws which I suppose it will be necessary for you to make I desire you would Remember the Ladies, and be more generous and favorable to them than your ancestors. Do not put such unlimited power into the hands of the husbands. Remember all men would be tyrants if they could. If particular care and attention is not paid to the ladies, we are determined to foment a rebellion, and will not hold ourselves bound by any laws in which we have no voice or representation."

Mercy Otis Warren
Mercy Otis Warren

But even though John Adams loved his wife very much and asked her for advice all the time, he answered, " As to your extraordinary Code of Laws, I cannot but laugh...We know better than to repeal our masculine systems," (see the letter here) and he did not include any rights for women in the Constitution. Abigail tried again, "I can not say that I think you very generous to the Ladies, for whilst you are proclaiming peace and good will to Men, Emancipating all Nations, you insist upon retaining an absolute power over Wives" (see the letter here). Mercy Otis Warren also tried to improve the legal position of women. But women could not vote until 1920, or be elected as President or as Senators or anything else.

Jews and Moslems:

Haym Solomon
Haym Solomon

Like the women, Jews also saw in the idea of the rights of man the possibility of getting equal rights for themselves. Haym (Chaim) Solomon, in 1784, asserted that, "I am a Jew; it is my own nation; I do not despair that we shall obtain every other privilege that we aspire to enjoy along with our fellow-citizens." Some of the Constitution writers, like Thomas Jefferson, agreed with Solomon that ""neither Pagan nor Mohammedan nor Jew ought to be excluded from the civil rights of the Commonwealth because of his religion." (This is Jefferson quoting John Locke). Washington also assured the Jews in 1790 that, "All possess alike liberty of conscience and immunities of citizenship... for happily the Government of the United States, which gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance, requires only that they who live under its protecture, should demean themselves as good citizens." The Jews did get some protections: the Bill of Rights says that the government can not make any law about religion, and from the beginning non-Christians could vote in the United States. But they didn't really get an equal voice in government. No Jews were elected to Congress until 1844. In some states, like Maryland and North Carolina, non-Christians could not legally be judges or elected officials for more than fifty years after the Constitution passed.


A petition presented by African-Americans to the courts of Massachusetts in 1777

Black people, both slaves and free, also tried to get equal rights under the new Constitution. In 1777, Prince Hall and eight other black men wrote a petition to the courts of Massachusetts saying, "that your Petitioners apprehend that they have in Common with all other men a Natural and Unalienable Right to that freedom which the Grat Parent of the Universe that Bestowed equally on all menkind and which they have Never forfeited by any Compact or agreement whatever." Some white men, like Henry Laurens of South Carolina, agreed that black men were "as well entitled to freedom as themselves." James Otis called slavery "the most shocking violation of the laws of nature."

Prince Hall
Prince Hall

Most of the northern states, beginning with Vermont, gradually ended slavery and black men gained the right to vote in the northern states. In his first draft of the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson said that among the other bad things that the King of England had done was that "he has waged cruel war against human nature itself, violating its most sacred rights of life and liberty in the persons of a distant people [the Africans] who never offended him, captivating and carrying them into slavery in another hemisphere, or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither." But the other white men made him take that part out. The black people didn't get their rights from the United States government. Instead, the rich white men writing the Constitution agreed that only rich white men could vote, and they agreed that when the census takers were counting the population of each state, a black man would count as only three-fifths as much as a white man. A lot of men thought that slavery would soon die out on its own anyway, and it might have, except for the invention of the cotton gin about this same time.

Native Americans:

Like women and black people, Native Americans were not allowed to vote in the first hundred years of the United States government. John Adams was surprised to find that, because the Declaration of Independence said all men were created equal, even "Indians slighted their Guardians and Negroes grew insolent to their Masters." (see the letter here) The Constitution (Article I, section 2) says that "Indians not taxed" should not even be counted in the census at all. The men who wrote the Constitution thought that Native Americans belonged to their own group, and were not part of the United States at all: they were not American citizens. Native American men did not get the right to vote until 1889, and then only if they left their tribes and lived like white men. It was 1924 before tribal Indians could vote.

Poor white men:

The way the Constitution was written in 1789, which white men could vote was left up to the states. In most states, you could only vote if you were a white man - AND you owned property, like a house or a farm or a store. If you rented your house and worked on somebody else's farm or in somebody else's store, then you couldn't vote. This meant that most white men living in the United States at this time could not vote. Rich men said this would make sure that only smart, sensible people voted.

Taking all these people together, just after the Revolutionary War only about a quarter of the grownup people in the United States could vote. Children and teenagers, as they are today, were also excluded, even though there were many more children than grownups in the United States at that time.

More about the Constitution
More about the Bill of Rights

Bibliography and further reading about the Constitution:

The United States Constitution
Thirteen Colonies
The Iroquois
The Revolutionary War
American History home

Professor Carr

Karen Eva Carr, PhD.
Assoc. Professor Emerita, History
Portland State University

Professor Carr holds a B.A. with high honors from Cornell University in classics and archaeology, and her M.A. and PhD. from the University of Michigan in Classical Art and Archaeology. She has excavated in Scotland, Cyprus, Greece, Israel, and Tunisia, and she has been teaching history to university students for a very long time.

Professor Carr's PSU page

Help support! (formerly "History for Kids") is entirely supported by your generous donations and by our sponsors. Most donors give about $10. Can you give $10 today to keep this site running? Or give $50 to sponsor a page?

Now that the weather's nice, try some of these outdoor activities! How about bicycle polo, or archery for a Medieval Islam day? Or kite flying or making a compass for a day in Medieval China? How about making a shaduf for a day in Ancient Egypt? Holding an Ancient Greek Olympic Games or a medieval European tournament? Building a Native American wickiup?